Father of Austin Metcalf Speaks Out on Son’s Murder and Trial Outcome

Jeff Metcalf, the father of murdered teen Austin Metcalf, discusses his views on the recently released evidence and the trial’s result. He criticizes the media for politicizing his son’s murder and focusing on race instead of character. Metcalf talks about the ongoing healing process for his family and the effects on Austin’s twin brother.

“They’re looking for their 15 minutes of fame, or their clickbait or their clicks. They’re just looking to monetize the death of my son,” Metcalf shared on “The Will Cain Show.”

His comments align with newly released evidence providing more clarity on the fatal stabbing incident in 2025. Police body camera footage shows Karmelo Anthony claiming responsibility for the stabbing when officers take him into custody.

“I’m not alleged. I did it,” Anthony said in his interaction with the responding officer.

Metcalf responds to comments by Sunny Hostin from “The View,” who suggested she could not understand why Anthony’s case wasn’t considered self-defense. Metcalf disputes her opinion, stating that those without knowledge of the case facts should avoid public speculation.

The trial focused on the question of self-defense, with some media personalities supporting this argument. However, Anthony received a conviction for first-degree murder and a 35-year prison sentence.

Jeff Metcalf expresses disappointment that the case became intertwined with discussions of race.

“We don’t see color. So, all I see is character in people. I don’t care what color you are. I want to judge you on how you treat people,” Metcalf emphasizes.

He also showed some empathy towards Karmelo Anthony, who appeared isolated during sensitive moments of the trial as his family left the courtroom when the verdict was pronounced.

Metcalf mentions the absence of any apology or remorse from Anthony’s family.

“No apology, no remorse?” Metcalf confirmed. “Nothing.”

Reflecting on Austin’s memory, Metcalf shares that his son was a compassionate leader dedicated to helping others. Austin played a supportive role for younger students transitioning to high school sports.

Jeff Metcalf concludes, recognizing that the trauma from losing Austin will be something the family carries for the rest of their lives.